05 March 2010

Odd numbers

Let's imagine we have two bags. In one bag, let's call it N-bag we put numbered balls, in the sequence 1,2,3,...; in the other bag, let's call it E-bag, we put only the even numbered balls 2,4,6,...; the procedure is as follow:

step 1: we put ball-1 in N-bag
step 2: we put ball-2 in N-bag and another ball-2 in E-bag
step 3: we put ball-3 in N-bag
step 4: we put ball-4 in N-bag and another ball-4 in E-bag
etc.

Which bag has the most balls, N-bag or E-bag? In mathematical terms, has the set of natural numbers more elements than the set of even numbers? Intuition would say so, as we fill the N-bag at twice the pace of the E-bag. There is also this fantastic demonstration I have found.

DEMONSTRATION
Let's call N the number of elements of the N-bag, and E the number of elements of the E-bag. Let's build a bag made only with odd numbers, the O-bag. To make this bag, we take out from the N-bag an exact copy of the E-bag. Now, if the N-bag and the E-bag would have the same number of elements, the O-bag would be empty. However, by construction, the O-bag is not empty, therefore the N-bag has more elements than the E-bag.

In more mathematical language, if we call N the number of elements of the Natural number set, and E the number of elements of the even number set, then O, defined as the number of elements of the odd number set is O=N-E.
If N=E than O=0.
But there is a number 3 which is odd, and therefore O cannot be 0, which means N is not equal to E.



It looks great, only it is wrong! N=E=O, but the demonstration does not fit the margin of this post.

5 comments:

Nat Busa said...

The only thing you have demonstrated is that you should never attempt to demonstrate mathematics in non-mathematical terms.

Giuseppe said...

The correctness of this comment is not demonstrated.

Nat Busa said...

About your previous comment:

If you refer to your own comment, wow, that brings the discussion to an entirely new level ...

Nat Busa said...

I just noticed that this is one of the few articles which is not tagged as "sex". Kind of weird with all these balls spinning around in and out the bags ...

mathematics anonymous said...

Natalino - wow, this casts a whole different light on yesterday's discussion re: balls!